You are here: silicon.com > Financial Services > News

Anger at card fraud reporting changes

Police pass buck to banks

By Julian Goldsmith

Published: 2 April 2007 13:29 GMT

Changes to reporting procedures for plastic card fraud have come into effect - but one critic is warning the changes may make things easier for fraudsters.

From now on, card fraud will be reported to banks, which will then choose to forward the report to the authorities if they deem it is necessary.

Are we going to get to the situation that if your house is burgled, you have to report it to your insurance company?

The Home Office said from 1 April new procedures under the Fraud Act 2006 mean banks and financial institutions become the first point of contact for cheque, plastic card and online fraud offences.

The Home Office said in a statement: "In most cases consumers will be required to report these crimes to their bank or building society directly and not to the police. The financial institution will then pass the details of the relevant crime on to the police."

It said the changes follow discussions with the Association of Chief Police Officers and the financial sector, with the main aim to reduce the level of bureaucracy involved in fraud recording and to streamline reporting and the initial investigation of such crimes.

The new rules cover England, Wales and Northern Ireland.

silicon.com Financial Services

Get the latest financial services news straight to your inbox. Sign up for the FS newsletter today!

But Andrew Goodwill, MD of security company Early Warning, believes this will allow banks to let themselves off the hook and hide the true extent of card fraud suffered by UK card-holders.

Online retailers are especially vulnerable, as banks are not liable for Card Not Present (CNP) fraud and will be less inclined to forward such reports to the police.

He added that bank staff are not trained to take reports in the same way as the police, so vital evidence might be missed, making it harder for fraudsters to be tracked down.

He said: "It's not fair to let banks act as judge and jury for consumers. Fraud is an offence and it should be dealt with by the police. Are we going to get to the situation that if your house is burgled, you have to report it to your insurance company? The police should not be allowed to negate their responsibility for fraud."

  1. Zones
  2. Management
  3. Networks
  4. Software
  5. IT Services
  6. Hardware
  1. Verticals
  2. Public Sector
  3. Financial Services
  4. Retail & Leisure

silicon.com Financial Services
Get the latest financial services news straight to your inbox. Sign up for the FS newsletter today!


  • Jobs
Oracle - Developeors - Risk IT - TIER ONE INVESTMENT BANK

One of the world's leading investment banks is looking for a number of experienced developers to join their architecture team within Risk IT and act ...

Project Controller - SAP - Primavera

We will require a current copy of a passport, driving license, ID card or NI card will be required as part of the registration process This ...

Sales Representative - Europe

We will require a current copy of a passport, driving license, ID card or NI card will be required as part of the registration process. This ...

Nick Beecham and Belinda Doshi
No more tax breaks for offshoring?
Financial services firms must prepare now for 2010 legal changes

Tim Ferguson
On a new Voyager, tackling fraud and the intellectual challenge
Interview: Nationwide IT director, Peter Stafford

Nick Heath
David Lister on smart grids and why he left RBS
Interview: National Grid CIO

Andy Jones
Why banks will push ahead with offshoring
Comment: Even if they don't want to

Catherine Stagg-Macey
Legacy IT holding back insurers
Comment: Economic crisis means finance giants must step lively

Julian Goldsmith
The City fund manager with no IT department
Q&A: How asset management is embracing the cloud...

Agenda Setters 2009
Welcome to the ninth annual Agenda Setters poll – silicon.com's list of the top 50 most influential individuals in the technology and IT industries, from techies and CIOs to entrepreneurs and business leaders. Find out more in our latest special report.




Quick Sitemap Links: