By John Borland, 8 March 2005 11:50
NEWS
Moscow prosecutors have declined to press criminal charges against a popular internet site that sells MP3s for just pennies, according to Russian news reports.
Record industry groups in the United States and Europe are trying to close the Russian AllofMP3.com, which offers downloads of MP3s - including songs from The Beatles and other groups that have not authorised digital distribution - for just a few cents per song.
Late last month, Moscow police completed an investigation of the issue and recommended to prosecutors that the site be charged with copyright violations. The International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI) also submitted a formal complaint about the site.
On Friday, Russian news agency Tass reported that prosecutors had declined to press criminal charges, citing specifics of Russian copyright law.
A spokeswoman for IFPI said Monday that the organisation had not heard an official response from the Moscow prosecutors.
IFPI spokeswoman Fiona Harley said: "We have received no confirmation of any decision, and we do not expect it for some time. However, if it is true that the prosecutor has not taken the case this would be very disappointing, considering the blatant and large-scale infringement that continues to take place."
The tussle over AllofMP3.com highlights the difficulties that copyright companies are having around the world, faced with myriad versions of laws that are often imperfectly adapted to new internet distribution models.
The Russian site says it has legal rights to sell the music in the form of licences from the Russian Multimedia and Internet Society. Record labels say that group does not have the authority to grant distribution rights to their music.
Similar issues have arisen in Spain, where a pair of Net companies began distributing music online citing the approval of local licence authorities. Record labels sued both, but only one - Weblisten.com - remains in operation.
The IFPI spokeswoman said the group would pursue the case further if the Moscow prosecutor takes no action.
John Borland writes for CNET News.com.
Comments
There are 5 comments. Join the discussion
1. Withheld
When jobs go offshore for cost savings and because it's cheaper we hear the excuse that it's an international business world and we have to go with the flow or be left behind. Surely giving the consumer the ability to source the product at the best possible price is part of the international free market economy.
2. Mark Hosey
The music industry certainly is in a bit of turmoil. For every MP3 web site they close down one or two more pop up and they've been reduced to hunting and prosecuting individual downloaders. It might deter a few but it won't ever stop the majority. Surely they're eventually going to have to face up to the fact that recorded music is now cheap! I believe that recorded music's only purpose in the future will be to promote the live show, the concert, the gig! And then at last we will get rid of the parasites and dross from the music industry. It will instead, I hope, become an industry where only strong, talented and hard working acts survive. The rest will be ignored. Long live the MP3 sites!
3. anonymous
"Face Facts: Recorded music is now cheap". Let's see, digital music is just non-interactive software. Why stop the cost cutting there?
4. anonymous
How I love this! The record companies aren't bigger than Russian law! YESSSSSSSSSSSS!
5. anonymous
Hopefully this will kill off kiddy pop
If the income of the record companys is hit enough they wont be able to afford to give there crappy engineered pop bands the publicity required to get the kids to buy it. Then we can get back to whoever has the tallent being successfull and have some decent music to listen to.