You are here: silicon.com > Public Sector > News

NHS IT refresh to face independent inquiry

Concern over "viability" of multi-billion pound upgrade...

Tags: nhs cfh, richard granger, granger, npfit

By Tom Espiner

Published: 25 April 2006 08:40 GMT

An independent inquiry will be held later this year into the government's multi-billion pound upgrade of the NHS IT systems, which has been widely criticised by experts.

A group of UK computer academics met with Richard Granger, NHS IT director general, last Thursday to discuss their concerns about the National Programme for IT (NPfIT).

Professor Ross Anderson of Cambridge University attended last week's meeting, where he expressed his concerns about the NPfIT.

He told silicon.com sister site ZDNet UK: "There is very widespread concern about the viability of NPfIT. We visited Granger and explained our concerns to him. He agreed that an independent review should be undertaken. We have been asked to propose terms of reference for the review and are consulting on that now. We plan to get back to him with a proposal shortly."

A total of 23 computer science academics wrote to Granger earlier this month to express their concerns over the programme, including Anderson and Frank Land, visiting professor of information systems at the London School of Economics. Land agrees that the project needs independent scrutiny.

Land said: "This is a very complex project, and by their nature very complex projects tend to get into trouble. The interactions that occur are unpredictable. An independent review is necessary because people get involved in a 'group thinking process' and can't see tangential things outside the group."

The government has claimed the programme will modernise the UK's health system, and deliver a range of benefits. Critics, however, have claimed the government has failed to recognise the risks and challenges that are inherent in such a massive project.

The programme was originally budgeted to cost £6.2bn but in late 2004 the Department of Health admitted the final bill could reach £30bn.

The NHS said last week's meeting was "constructive and fruitful", and would be followed by a second meeting to hammer out details of an inquiry.

NHS Connecting For Health said in a statement: "The representatives expressed their agreement with and support for the overall goals of the programme as expressed in the meeting. There was agreement that a constructive and pragmatic independent review of the programme could be valuable.

"The parties agreed to meet again to consider further details of how such a review might best be conducted and its terms of reference."

Tom Espiner and Graeme Wearden write for ZDNet UK

  1. Zones
  2. Management
  3. Networks
  4. Software
  5. IT Services
  6. Hardware
  1. Verticals
  2. Public Sector
  3. Financial Services
  4. Retail & Leisure

silicon.com Public Sector
Get the latest public sector news straight to your inbox. Sign up for the PS newsletter today!


  • Jobs
Junior Level Test Analyst - Exceptional Academics Required - London

Huxley Associates is seeking a junior level test analyst to join a Top Financial Derivatives House to work within their Equities IT department. The ...

Senior Physicist/Engineer - Cambridge

Essential skills: -Good academics, either good first degree or a PhD in Physics or a related Engineering subject -Good engineering experience, with ...

Graduate or mid-level Java Developer - Top academics only

Graduate or mid-level Java Developer required in Hertfordshire (20 mins from London Kings Cross) to work on mathematically intensive Java ...

Nick Heath
Let's shine a light into the public sector IT money pit
With £16bn being spent, why is productivity still falling?

Tim Ferguson
BBC is taking tech seriously, so give it a break!
Auntie is the envy of the world but doesn't get the credit it deserves at home...

Peter Cochrane
Peter Cochrane's Blog: Open info for all?
Government stonewalling citizens

Nick Heath
Home Office CIO on taming tech and why ID cards are good news
Interview: Annette Vernon, Home Office CIO

Nick Heath
NHS records, Google and Microsoft: Where do you want your data?
Politicians: Heal thyself

Alan Hunt
NHS network: Time to get secure
Patient data in need of a check up

Agenda Setters 2009
Welcome to the ninth annual Agenda Setters poll – silicon.com's list of the top 50 most influential individuals in the technology and IT industries, from techies and CIOs to entrepreneurs and business leaders. Find out more in our latest special report.




Quick Sitemap Links: