You are here: silicon.com > Public Sector > News

Call for e-voting to be scrapped amid security fears

Official observers express "deep concerns" after May election trials

Tags: open rights group, e-voting

By Andy McCue

Published: 25 June 2007 12:40 BST

Privacy campaigners have called for any further e-voting trials to be scrapped after uncovering evidence of poor security, inadequate audit trails, equipment failures and an over-dependence on technology suppliers during the May local elections.

The Open Rights Group (ORG) had a team of 25 officially accredited election observers at the e-voting and e-counting pilots and has expressed "deep concern" about the use of the technology in a report of its findings.

Five councils offered internet and telephone voting and six authorities were approved to use electronic counting technology at the May local elections.

Despite our best efforts, we have been unable to verify the accuracy of the elections we monitored.

-- Jason Kitcat, ORG e-voting co-ordinator

Numerous problems were observed with the e-voting technologies by the ORG. In Swindon laptops and live electronic voting registers were unreliable and kept crashing, while in Rushmoor an online ballot paper temporarily included a Labour party logo next to the Conservative party candidate.

The observers also found evidence of weak physical security of the e-voting equipment, such as PCs with open ports and networking devices in openly accessible public areas.

Additional concerns are raised in the report about the alleged vulnerability of the system used to host internet voting for Rushmoor and South Buckinghamshire authorities. According to the report, the system could potentially allow hackers to steal authentication details, monitor how someone had cast their vote or change the contents of the online ballot paper.

The e-counting technology fared no better with observers describing "chaotic scenes" that led to significant delays in the declaration of election results. Problems included scanner malfunctions and software errors.

All of this was compounded by a lack of technical knowledge among the returning officers responsible for ensuring the vote count is accurate and declaring the results, which led to a dangerous over-dependence on the suppliers of the equipment.

The ORG report said the actions of some vendors in trying to fix problems that arose on the day with the e-voting and e-counting equipment left a lack of a reliable audit trail.

The report said: "Returning officers and their deputies were observed to have little or no technical knowledge, leaving them unable to judge the quality of the technologies supplied. They were unable to monitor technical issues - and hence hold their suppliers to account."

The ORG is now calling for a halt in any further use of e-voting and e-counting technology until it is proven to be more robust, reliable and transparent.

Jason Kitcat, ORG's e-voting co-ordinator, said in the report: "We were surprised by the scale of the problems our team observed on polling day. Despite our best efforts, we have been unable to verify the accuracy of the elections we monitored."

  1. Zones
  2. Management
  3. Networks
  4. Software
  5. IT Services
  6. Hardware
  1. Verticals
  2. Public Sector
  3. Financial Services
  4. Retail & Leisure

silicon.com Public Sector
Get the latest public sector news straight to your inbox. Sign up for the PS newsletter today!


  • Jobs
Client Delivery Leader

You should also provide evidence of: - Outstanding client, people management and coaching skills - Enthusiasm and commitment to delivering quality ...

Lead Software Consultant

As a Lead Software Consultant you will have: * Proven experience in applications design, development and implementation methods, and demonstrable ...

Technical IT Infrastructure Manager

Qualifications are: - Academic qualifications to Degree level (or equivalent) - One of the following - MCSE and/or Cisco Certified - A full Driving ...

Martyn Hart
Is short-termism holding back public sector outsourcing?
Comment: Driving down bids can store up trouble

silicon.com
Inbox: YouTube surveillance, skills gap, Naked speak
"It is up to citizens to use them, and not just moan in comments to silicon.com"

Andy McCue
The McCue Interview: Phil Pavitt, CIO, Transport for London
On why he's trying to make IT boring…

Julian Goldsmith
Leading a horse to water
Profile: Government CIO John Suffolk

Steve Ranger
Editor's Blog: Time to take the politicians out of technology?
We've given them their chance...

Paul Bentham
Outsourcing - life after the contract
Just when you thought it was all nailed down...

CIO50 2008
The silicon.com CIO50 2008 profiles the most influential and innovative tech chiefs in the UK across all industries and organisation size, from the biggest FTSE100 companies to high growth dot-com start ups and the public sector. The list was voted on by the UK CIO community and a panel of experts. Find out more in our latest special report.




Quick Sitemap Links: