Seduced by cheap upfront costs…
By Nick Heath
Published: 4 April 2008 15:33 BST
Taxpayers' money is being squandered on public sector outsourcing deals where costs are ballooning up to 75 per cent more than the going market rate.
Lacklustre controls on spending over the full lifetime of government outsourcing contracts are leading to "poor value for money" because public sector organisations are lured by low upfront costs, claims Compass Management Consulting.
The consulting group made its claims in a submission to the government's Public Services Industry Review (PSIR) that is looking at how to improve efficiency in the £40bn-a-year public outsourcing market.
Nigel Hughes, consultant at Compass, said: "There is more focus in the public sector on the initial tender price and not the long-term price of the contract."
The submission says: "This leads to the "bid it thin and get it in" strategy of many outsourcing providers who price contracts at up to 18 per cent below market rate on day one rising to 30 per cent above market rate by year three of the contract.
There is "no accountability and no way of calibrating value for money as the contract runs" it says.
Top 10 government IT stories of 2007
Check out the government tech stories that made waves last year here.
It claims that providers are forced to "claw back" their losses after being pressured to lower their bid to win the tender.
Hughes called on the government to lay down a blueprint for best practice.
Compass said that managers and systems need to be put in place to work with supplier to monitor performance and control spending once the contract gets underway, similar to the setting up of a vendor management office.
The submission refers to a government agency paying 65 per cent above market rate for servers and storage and a major government department paying 20 per cent more for outsourced desktop, servers and infrastructure despite its scale.
The PSIR finished taking submissions on Friday 4 April, including from major outsourcing providers like LogicaCMG, and is being headed by DeAnne Julius after being commissioned by the Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform.
Very good points here & I really don't think they ...
Brian Murray
Outsourcing has so many benefits:
1) Cost Savings...
tinasilvee
Schools are next in this long line of public secto...
Sam Prince
I really would like someone to go to prison for th...
Roger Huffadine
Yep! Place I worked at - the 'Purchasing/Contracts...
James Button
We have a fantastic opportunityfor aPFI BidManager to look after the PFI Bid processfrom conception to completion, youwill be working with an ...
Participate in or co-ordinate the preparation and review of bid packages including work specifications, schedule commitments, cost objectives and ...
Job Title: Service Management ArchitectLocation: Berkshire, UKThis is a superb opportunity to join a leading provider of outsourced ...
Agenda Setters 2008
Welcome to the ninth annual Agenda Setters poll – silicon.com's list of the top 50 most influential individuals in the technology and IT industries, from techies and CIOs to entrepreneurs and business leaders. Find out more in our latest special report.
Stories from the web...
Copyright © 2008 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved. Top of page
Nick Heath
Next stop HMRC: How TfL CIO will shake up the taxman
Interview: Phil Pavitt, CIO Transport for London, on making IT boring
Gary Bettis
Public sector CIOs: It's your time to shine
Comment: Efficiency programme offers big challenges and opportunities
Gary Lynch
How e-coding can prevent NHS slip-ups
Barcodes to run in their blood
silicon.com
Inbox: Chip and PIN latest big IDea - and still no readers
"PIN numbers do not present much of a challenge to a determined crook"
Jo Best
From army officer to IT chief - CPS CIO David Jones
Profile: What IT and the military have in common
silicon.com
Inbox: Government IT ignoring red lights?
"The civil servants who specify these projects are not competent technically"