Home Office faces security criticism
By Tom Espiner
Published: 6 November 2008 08:32 GMT
Home Secretary Jacqui Smith will invite high-street businesses today to tender to be biometrics enrolment centres for the National Identity Scheme, which the government will use to issue ID cards.
The Home Office wants to use the tender process to gauge whether businesses such as post offices and banks would be interested in participating in taking fingerprints from people for the scheme, silicon.com sister site ZDNet UK understands. It also hopes to formulate a document, called the Frontline Services Prospectus, outlining how biometric enrolment would be carried out by businesses.
ZDNet UK also understands that the Post Office has not been approached directly by the Home Office to submit a tender.
ID cards: Latest news
♦  ID cards on driving licences - 'law can't stop us'
♦  'ID card guinea pig' pilots ready to call in lawyers
♦  ID card 'will drown in a billion mismatches'
♦  Photos: A first glimpse of the ID card
♦  One million ID cards every year from 2009
Anti-ID cards campaigner Phil Booth told ZDNet UK on Wednesday that the government was trying to sell high-street firms an idea that would not work. "The Home Office is selling businesses a pig in a poke," Booth said. "What company would want to invest millions in a service that will be scrapped at the first opportunity?"
Booth added that the Home Office proposal "absolutely undermines security".
"If they're taking fingerprints on the high street, they simply cannot guarantee locking prints to details," he said. "The only way they could have done that is in an interrogation centre, with some official scrutinising documentation, then walking you over to the scanner to take your prints."
Booth suggested that a high-street-based system would be open to fraud and systems error, and could lead to chaos.
The Home Office declined to comment on the scheme.
Original article: Home Office looks to high street for ID biometrics from ZDNet UK
They just don't get it do they? If they start taki...
Drew Stephenson
I agree with the last part of the article regardin...
Richard Davies
so I go dumpster diving for some documents or inve...
Karen Challinor
Why do they try and sell the ID card and associate...
Radical Meldrew
If they (the govt) go ahead with this ridiculous s...
just ask Jacky
A good team player is required who seeks to involve others at all times.Additional informationThis post will require regular travel throughout the UK ...
Store Manager- Value High Street RetailerTo apply, please send your CV to mr@detail2retail.com or click the "Apply" button below.The Company:Our ...
Assistant Manager / Assistant Store Manager - Leading High Street RetailerThe Company:Our client is one of the leading high street retailers within ...
Agenda Setters 2008
Welcome to the ninth annual Agenda Setters poll – silicon.com's list of the top 50 most influential individuals in the technology and IT industries, from techies and CIOs to entrepreneurs and business leaders. Find out more in our latest special report.
Stories from the web...
Copyright © 2008 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved. Top of page
silicon.com
Inbox: ID cards U-turn: The end is nigh?
"Great news and hopefully the beginning of the end for this crazy ID project"
Nick Heath
Next stop HMRC: How TfL CIO will shake up the taxman
Interview: Phil Pavitt, CIO Transport for London, on making IT boring
Gary Bettis
Public sector CIOs: It's your time to shine
Comment: Efficiency programme offers big challenges and opportunities
Gary Lynch
How e-coding can prevent NHS slip-ups
Barcodes to run in their blood
silicon.com
Inbox: Chip and PIN latest big IDea - and still no readers
"PIN numbers do not present much of a challenge to a determined crook"
Jo Best
From army officer to IT chief - CPS CIO David Jones
Profile: What IT and the military have in common