Whether it makes them more efficient or not...
Published: 10 November 2008 16:29 GMT
Despite calls for more money to give all frontline police officers access to PDAs and help boost the time bobbies spend on the beat, not all officers that have tested the technology claim are convinced.
In July, the Home Office announced an extra £25m to put thousands more mobile devices in the hands of police, topping up a a £50m spend for police PDAs announced back in May.
However, the House of Commons Home Affairs Committee has called for even more cash to be made available to mobilise every front line bobby.
In a report into government plans to update policing practices for the modern era, Policing in the 21st Century, the Committee states: "Personal digital assistants can significantly increase the amount of time that police officers spend on visible patrol and dealing with incidents outside the station, and reduce the time they spend on paperwork."
"We welcome the Home Secretary's recent grant of £50m to fund PDAs in 19 English forces and her promises of a further £25m but recognise that many forces were disappointed not to win funding bids. We recommend that sufficient funding is made available as soon as possible to enable all frontline officers to have access to a PDA," the report adds.
Inspector Jim Hitch, of Bedfordshire Police, told the committee after his force deployed PDAs the amount of time officers spent in the station dropped from almost half (46 per cent) to just over a third (36 per cent) - where it has remained. Hitch added visible patrol time went up from 14 per cent to 19 per cent, while time spent by officers dealing with incidents rose from 19 per cent to 26 per cent.
However some PDA users claimed the technology made them less efficient, not more.
Seventy per cent of the 349 officers surveyed by the Scottish Police Federation said the PDAs they trialled had made them less efficient, while around a quarter said there was 'no change'. Only a small percentage - less than 10 per cent - said handheld devices made them more efficient. The committee also heard software problems with the Scottish trial had meant electronic notes were often corrupted, forcing officers to spend time re-entering evidence back at the station.
Another potential problem associated with PDA use was around police officers' perceptions of their personal security. Seventy-five per cent of the Scottish officers surveyed said they felt less safe using PDAs, rather than paper notebooks, because of the concentration required to operate them during potentially confrontational situations. However the report noted Staffordshire Police recommend officers resort to communicating by radio rather than through the PDA if they suspect an offender may become violent.
According to the committee, 19 police forces in England and eight in Scotland have won bids for 10,000 mobile data devices to be delivered between September 2008 and February 2009. The total cost to a force of equipping a police officer with mobile IT is estimated to be between £3,000 and £6,500 per officer over five years.
Figures from Thames Valley, West Yorkshire and Bedfordshire forces put the average cost - for training, infrastructure and the device itself - at 80p to £1 per officer per day.
The committee took evidence from BlackBerry maker RIM, which estimates it would cost £50m to purchase and provide BlackBerry devices for all forces.
RIM has currently deployed 14,000 devices across 28 UK forces - or around three-quarter of all devices deployed in the country - according to the committee.
In a previous report - on police funding - the committee notes it criticised "insufficient progress" on introducing police PDAs and recommended Chief Constables ensure they are introduced in all forces "as a matter of urgency". However, the report notes, this has not yet been achieved.
Develop and manage project governance including steering committee meetings, sponsor meetings, project team meetings, status reports, etc. Establish ...
The NOC team: Actively monitors the BlackBerry Infrastructure Reactively resolves any incidents which occur and ensure these are responded to ...
You will provide technical support on all PCs, Laptops, PDAs, peripherals, applications and operating systems (including Lotus Notes, MS Office and ...
Agenda Setters 2008
Welcome to the ninth annual Agenda Setters poll – silicon.com's list of the top 50 most influential individuals in the technology and IT industries, from techies and CIOs to entrepreneurs and business leaders. Find out more in our latest special report.
Stories from the web...
Copyright © 2008 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved. Top of page
Nick Heath
Next stop HMRC: How TfL CIO will shake up the taxman
Interview: Phil Pavitt, CIO Transport for London, on making IT boring
Gary Bettis
Public sector CIOs: It's your time to shine
Comment: Efficiency programme offers big challenges and opportunities
Gary Lynch
How e-coding can prevent NHS slip-ups
Barcodes to run in their blood
silicon.com
Inbox: Chip and PIN latest big IDea - and still no readers
"PIN numbers do not present much of a challenge to a determined crook"
Jo Best
From army officer to IT chief - CPS CIO David Jones
Profile: What IT and the military have in common
silicon.com
Inbox: Government IT ignoring red lights?
"The civil servants who specify these projects are not competent technically"