Surveillance passports just not cricket, say civil liberties groups
By Jo Best
Published: 30 March 2004 16:35 GMT
Civil liberties groups from both sides of the Atlantic have joined forces to oppose the proposed introduction and cross-border sharing of biometrics and RFID in more than one billion passports worldwide.
Human rights organisations from Europe, North America, Australia and Asia have sent an open letter to the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) railing against plans to create an international 'identity register' that would force the inclusion of biometrics and controversial RFID tracking tags in all passports by 2015.
Among the 39 groups who put pen to paper are: Privacy International, the Foundation for Information Policy Research, the Electronic Frontier Foundation and the American Civil Liberties Union.
The ICAO will be meeting in Cairo next week and will be discussing the scheme. If the ICAO approves it, facial mapping and tracking tags would become mandatory, with fingerprinting also on the drawing board, depending on the preferences of individual governments.
Home Secretary David Blunkett has already proved his fondness for biometrics of all kinds when he announced late last year that there would be trials for biometric ID, with iris or fingerprint recognition potentially on the cards.
The US has also gone big on biometrics, photographing and fingerprinting visitors crossing its borders.
As well as voicing fears that the proposed database may "threaten [human] rights", the letter adds that the chosen standard of facial recognition may be unsound.
"The ICAO standards do not govern the use to which the facial recognition is put but even the most reliable uses of this technology - one-to-one verification using recent photographs - have been shown in US government tests to be highly unreliable, returning a false non-match [where technology doesn't recognise people with a valid photo] rate of five per cent and a false match rate of one per cent," it says, adding that there may be the potential for oppressive regimes to get their hands on methods of surveillance that were previously inaccessible.
"We hope that the choices of biometrics have been driven primarily by logistical and commercial concerns and were not intended to facilitate the conversion of travel systems into a global infrastructure of surveillance. But we are deeply concerned that this may become their unintended consequence," it concludes.
A couple of firm taps with a hammer or two or thre...
M Hosey
The only people who could oject to this are those ...
Anonymous
I think we need to do something for national secur...
Anonymous
"The only people who could..." Lol good punchline...
Joe
"And he causes ALL, both small and great, rich and...
H J Gerbasi
BT plans passport checks to slash ID fraud
But you'll still need to keep an eye on your bin...
'Witness intimidation' hampering fraud convictions
Courts and legal system are ill-prepared for hearing technical cases...
Zombies are after your ID
Bot nets are increasingly looking to steal valuable personal information...
SurfControl rides the spyware wave
But warns time is running out for anybody favouring "buy" rather than "build" as an entry strategy...
Bloggers become spyware spreaders
Unwitting accomplices...
Stories from around the web...
Identity theft - the facts VNUNet.com
Got an identity crisis? Join the queue The Observer
White-Collar Crime: What's your identity? LegalWeek
Drop the jargon from privacy policies, says privacy chief Out-Law.com
ID 'neglect' harming consumers This is Money
Make your voice heard
silicon.com and the Bathwick Group have created an opportunity for business and IT executives to share their experience with each other and thus enhance their knowledge of the IT marketplace.
Join our research panel, and you'll be asked to participate in short surveys - and then will be privy to the answers of all your colleagues, as we send you tailored versions of the results.
Extras include complementary passes to silicon.com events and survey prizes such as iPods. Plus, there are the obvious networking opportunities with your fellow panellists.
For more about the Research Panel and how to join, click here
Copyright © 2008 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved. Top of page