silicon survey: Readers back mobile car ban

But overwhelmingly against complete ban that would outlaw hands free kits…

NEWS A government ban on the use of mobile phones while driving has been given a firm thumbs up by silicon.com readers. The overwhelming majority (78 per cent) of those who completed a silicon.com survey said talking into a mobile phone handset held to the ear, with one hand on the wheel should be made illegal. But at the same time most readers - 83 per cent - were against a complete in-car mobile ban that would even outlaw the use of hands free kits. In fact, while 22 per cent of respondents virtuously claimed to never use a mobile while driving, almost half do use hands free kits on the road and 15 per cent of silicon.com readers admitted to driving with a mobile clamped to their ear. Despite the fact the government claims talking on mobiles while driving can lead to serious accidents, respondents to the survey took a lenient view towards punishment, with most favouring a few points on drivers' licences or a small fine of up to £250. The option of landing handheld-happy drivers with larger fines of up to £2,000 was preferred by a smaller but still significant proportion of readers but less than three per cent thought the offence should result in time spent behind bars. A separate survey by health and safety consultants Croner showed that the nation was split over the issue of hands free mobiles in cars, with only 45 per cent of people supporting their use. silicon.com surveyed 2,325 readers between 9 July and 15 July.

Comments

There is 1 comment. Join the discussion

  1. 1. Chi Tang

    What a bunch of pathetic stupid readers you have. Increase fines, complete ban and prison sentences for people using mobile phones whilst driving?!! Yeah whatever.

    I guess we should have prison sentences for all mums with babies crying in the back seat, people listening to the radio, drivers arguing about directions with their partner, chewing gum, reaching for sweets, doing make up etc etc.

    If I held a banana to my ear and started talking to myself, would I be banned for that? Off course I would, if I caused a serious accident whilst talking to a banana. So why don't they have a law that caters for people talking to a banana whilst driving? Because it's already covered within the dangerous driving law or driving without due care and attention.

    Ask the governmment how many accidents are caused by people using a mobile phone - I guarantee you that you will find it's an insignificant percentage and as major cause of accidents it wouldnt even register on a nano scale. And now ask them how many accidents are caused by someone overtaking an unreasonably slow and senile driver. How many accidents are caused by some middle class mother letting her child run ahead of her because her hands are all full carrying Selfridges bags to her overtly large people carrier even though there's only one child in the family.

    The point is, the law already covers driving without due care so there's no need to have additional laws for mobile phones, chewing gum, listening to the radio, eating food, arguing with your partner and talking to a banana. What causes accidents is people not having the mental capability to drive safely whilst all these other things are going on around us. And if you dont have the mental capability to do that then you shouldnt be driving anyway.

    Chi Y Tang

    • 25 November 2004 10:49
    • Add comment

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in.

You can also log in with Facebook. Log in or create your silicon.com account below

  • Login

Will not be displayed with your comment

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy.

Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Membership FAQ

Get silicon.com's daily newsletter

  • Register on silicon.com

    Enter your email to register

Keep in touch with silicon.com

silicon.com newsletters