Leader: 3G won't catch on 'because we can't lie'

"I'm still in the office, working hard..." won't work on video conferencing...

By silicon.com, 21 January 2004 18:20

It would seem the beauty of SMS text messaging is that it allows you to lie to your other half.

"Sorry love, in the office, working late. Boring! Won't be home until about 11 - put the kids to bed, and I'll get a take-away."

Sounds familiar... that's because it's probably a message you've sent from the pub while waiting to buy your fourth round of drinks.

Or at least 45 per cent of respondents to a recent survey admitted to using text messages to lie about their location. Perhaps the uses could include more sinister cover-ups even than lying about being down the pub, such as marital infidelity.

But this conveniently dishonest device may be about to be taken away from us with the onset of 3G phones - the horribly honest medium of video conferencing will easily betray you when you are not in the office (unless pubs can be encouraged to install an 'office wall', in front of which drinkers can stand to conference home).

Mike Grenville, CEO of mobile messaging association 160 Characters, said: "Does technology mean we lie more? Maybe it does.

"Maybe this is also a reason why 3G video conferencing won't catch on. After all, maybe there are some benefits to the other half not being able to see where you are."

Admittedly if you've already set a precedent for lying then you may be capable of squeezing out 'video conferencing not working but I still am... won't be home 'til late'. Just make sure you get yourself on a different network to the other half.

Comments

There are 3 comments. Join the discussion

  1. 1. Jonathan Schofield

    Many many years ago (35-40) Mad Magazine ran a strip cartoon about video phones and how users had a little portable 'pull down' screen on which was drawn a convincing background to fool people they were in the office etc. Could be a marketing opportunity.

  2. 2. anonymous

    Just shows how many dishonest people you have to deal with every day. If you cannot be honest with your wife then there is no hope for you.....

  3. 3. Jonathan Meldrum

    3g is just telcos believing their own PR and paying through the nose for licences for a duff product. The pressure to recoup costs is going to warp their sense of how much a consumer will pay, and pricing won't be 'real-world' for ages, with consequent lack of take-up; the cost of the proper infrastructure will be astronomical, and we all know the handsets don't work properly anyway. Looks like a 20 billion pound write-down.

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in.

Log in or create your silicon.com account below

Will not be displayed with your comment

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy.

Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Membership FAQ