Peter Cochrane's Blog: GPS changes everything

Mostly for the better...

By Peter Cochrane, 28 November 2005 11:45

COMMENT

Written while flying from Heathrow to Istanbul and dispatched to silicon.com from Istanbul Airport via a free Wi-Fi service

I remember buying a car when the heater was optional and a radio wasn't even on the list. Today our expectations are much higher, as are production standards and quality, and it is unthinkable that any vehicle wouldn't come complete with these items as standard. We have moved on, and the options list now includes automatic transmission, air conditioning, sound system upgrades, spoilers and GPS navigation systems. Soon these will all be standard too!

For the past six years I have enjoyed the benefit of having GPS in three successive vehicles, and in the past two years, in a succession of hire cars across the US. Beyond the comfort of air conditioning, GPS has made the greatest impact on my driving and me. No more reading of maps, and making errors on freeways when tired - GPS just takes care of it. Likewise, driving in a strange town or city is now a relatively stress-free experience. Just punch in the address or zip code and go - everything is taken care of. And should I find myself in a traffic jam, what could now be easier than a rapid re-route?

Some GPS systems have better interfaces than others but in my estimation the benefit always outweighs the interface pain. On the upside I see far more good interfaces than bad, and in my own car I think the design is one of the best applications of multimedia I have encountered anywhere. When national traffic management systems are linked in so I can be warned of developments such as traffic jams and be advised of the best alternative routings, the service will be complete. And should it be extended even further to advise on the optimum departure time, travel stops etc, then I will be ecstatic.

So is there a downside to all this? Well, because of my age I have developed a mind map of locations and distances/times across the UK and the US, along with maps of all the cities and towns I most commonly visit. For example, I feel equally at home in London, San Jose and San Francisco. Not so for young people it seems. Some are now buying their first car complete with GPS right off the bat and so no longer refer to a map from day one. Even cab and logistics companies are gradually adopting GPS to broaden the employee base and reduce operating costs.

Does this all matter? This seems to me to be on a par with the abandonment of mental arithmetic skills for the pocket calculator and spreadsheet. Older people worried about that too but the world still spins on its axis. At the same time, not having a sense of geography has, I think, a much broader impact that we should be more concerned about.

Having absolutely no idea where you are necessitates a GPS unit in your hand as well as in your car. Without a rudimentary mind map, people just make mistakes when entering data into a GPS unit. And when satellite lock is lost due to high buildings, wet trees and intense rain, the user is truly lost and prone to make erroneous decisions. The good news is that nano-gyros will soon afford us an inertial navigation facility that does not rely on satellites alone, and it will also work indoors. In addition, there are mobile telephone base stations capable of providing location estimate through triangulation and waypoint references.

We stand on the edge of a new era in terms of maps and mapping where individuals will contribute their location data, photographs and floor plans using mobile devices. In North America this has now started with people using GPS, cameras, PDAs and laptops to take photographs of views and intersections to augment and populate public maps built from satellite images. One motivation for this is the 'thin' nature of maps compared to the EU where accurate and extensive mapping has been a necessity of the near continuous wars of previous centuries. In contrast, North America was never afforded this advantage! So in a way we are again becoming the builders of maps, we are again to become the navigators - but this time around on a micro and a macro scale.

My guess is that soon we will have gone full circle and we will all have gained a new and a more intimate knowledge of our world, but through our own hand, and the use of the latest technology.

Comments

There are 6 comments. Join the discussion

  1. 1. James Couper-Johnston

    I agree wholeheartedly, and think GPS the single greatest advance is computer useability I've seen. It does that important essential of doing something necessary really well and improving people's lives.
    I share the concerns, too. I think we should still learn which way is North and which is South and look at a 'paper' map to understand the relative geography of places we visit. It's the same as learning basic mental arithmetic so that you can spot the obvious error caused by incorrect keying of a decimal point or transposing two numbers. If you have no idea what the answer should be yourself, you can't spot if the 'machine' has got it wrong.
    The other thing it might miss is the option to experiment. I've not yet seen a GPS system that has the choice quickest/shortest/prettiest/route-I've-never-used-before options... So there is still scope for human choice!!

  2. 2. Ed Carroll

    I would agree that the increasing availability and great advances in GPS have now delivered us a navigation platform that supersedes any of the before (and some!) It is a great technology; it’s efficient, saves resources, is always up to date and as Peter said; as long as you put in the correct information you will get to where you want to go! It seems like a great deal and certainly a technology that some people thought a decade ago was never going to be in reach of your average consumer! However aside from all the positives there is the negative that possibly won’t be noticed until it’s too late… to quote: “…GPS navigation systems. Soon these will all be standard too!” on the first take it still sounds like a great idea although do we take in to context the full implications of this? Being a driver, 10 years down the line if this were to happen you will have a globally tracked ID that at a very whim can be used to locate your vehicle to potentially anywhere in the world… this worries me; and it doesn’t take a great imagination to realise how this information could be used / abused…

    As with all great advances in technology they will be embraced by the masses; I just hope there are controls in place to stop this great technology being misused.

  3. 3. Stuart Walmsley

    I am, as most times, in agreement with Peter, however I think he has missed an important point. I have 2 sons, both with full blown GPS and PDA and Mobile Phones plus Bluetooth etc etc. However, they have both learned that when going on a "trip" its best to print out the GPS route then ask Dad to look at it, on average I can save them around 20% in milage and or convenience based upon my learned knowledge of both the UK and Europe! When I got my first car petrol was 4/10½ a gallon, that meant that 4 gallons was 19/6d (19 shillings and 6 pence) so we gave the pump attendant, yes he did it for us, a £ note and drove off leaving him a 6d (2.5p) tip. Having visisted the USA a few times I am now geographically au fait with most of the East Coast. My sons will never be able to do that as they trust their GPS and switch their brain off, how sad. BTW neither of them are good at mental arithmetic either! Allowing ones brain to stultify by the use of "modern" innovations is the major downfall of all these gadgets:(

  4. 4. Peter Cochrane

    It is always easy to look to the past through rose tinted specs, but the past wasn't that good. In fact, by and large it was crap!

    The world and technology moves on. I can remember slide rules, log tables, bicycles and walking too....

    I wonder if you are as good at multi-media and strategy games as your sons?
    Mine just outlcass me in the new and look on with wry amusement at my old fashioned ways!

  5. 5. aitianforever

    Great info, pity it is not so easy to find real information about GPS and the proper GPS information

  6. 6. michel fefer

    hello
    i have agree with it but there are some truth GPS does not work in cloudy places and rainy weather.
    Truth: GPS devices were originally developed for sailing - so they have to be waterproof. The GPS signals are not affected by clouds, rain, fog or snow - they work just as well if the day is wet or dry and they don’t mind thick cloud cover. GPS device can take a dunking in a cold beck or hot coffee and still work fine.

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in.

Log in or create your silicon.com account below

Will not be displayed with your comment

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy.

Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Membership FAQ