By Natasha Lomas, 4 June 2008 10:58
NEWS
A broadband speed report by UK fat pipe watcher and advice website thinkbroadband claims the countryside still lags some way behind urban areas - contrary to last week's Ofcom report hailing the end of a geographical digital divide in the UK for internet access.
Fat pipe speeds rarely live up to the theoretical maximums advertised by ISPs so the fastest UK region in the thinkbroadband survey - London - achieves an average download rate of 4.5Mbps. But this is almost double the rate in Northern Ireland (2.3Mbps), the region with the slowest average download speed.
Next most sluggish is Wales (2.6Mbps), then the South West (2.9Mbps) and Scotland (2.9Mbps), according to the data. Fastest after London are: the North East (3.6Mbps), the North West (3.4Mbps) and the East Midlands (3.3Mbps) - suggesting there is a rural vs urban split based on ADSL speed.
Broadband from A-Z
Click here for all there is on broadband, from fibre to zombies.
The advice website says broadband headline speeds in excess of 8Mbps are therefore less likely to be available in rural areas, adding that almost all telephone exchanges in areas such as London have a wide variety of LLU (local loop unbundling) operators, compared to under a quarter of the exchanges in Wales.
thinkbroadband found only a handful of speed tests achieved 7Mbps or faster in Wales, where in London just under 20 per cent of the tests achieved that download rate.
LLU has been key to achieving faster broadband speeds in the short term as BT's own next-gen ADSL tech - ADSL2+ (which promises a theoretical maximum of 24Mbps) - has taken longer to arrive.
Posting a recent reader comment on silicon.com about the rural/urban broadband divide, management consultant Dan Zamoyski said: "As a rural market-town dweller in Derbyshire, we are still waiting for the unbundling to take place at our exchange so we can get a non-BT speed of more than 2.2Mbps. Sadly, the urban/rural divide certainly still does exist!"
London doesn't have everything its own way, however. The fat pipe advice site also breaks speeds down by individual cities in the various regions.
The fastest city for broadband downloads is Edinburgh (4.41Mbps), with Greater London in second place (4.37Mbps) and Glasgow city in third (4.14Mbps). The Highlands of Scotland came bottom - with an average of 2.18Mbps - though only regions with speed tests from more than 40 unique postcodes were included in the ranking.
The average download speed in the UK is 3.2Mbps, according to thinkbroadband.
Comments
There are 3 comments. Join the discussion
1. Richard
Our dodgy phone line limits the speed:
Our broadband speed, dial-up speed and speech quality are dominated by the poor quality of our overhead line, by interference from street lights etc. and by flooded BT ducts.
Our local exchange permits "unbundling."
If our phone line went direct to the exchange - rather than to a BT street cabinet in the opposite direction - it would be about 0.5km.
When everything is dry and quiet, the maximum broadband speed is about 2Mbps.
At other times, the dial-up speed drops well below 20kbps.
Several times a year, the phone line fails completely; repairs take days.
2. anonymous
I live in a small Dorset town, and receive a nominal 8mb bradband package from a non-BT supplier
My mother lives in a village less than 3 miles away, and BT state that she cannot receive a broadband service, due to her distance from the exchange. Some other broadband suppliers believe they can offer a 2mb service to her address, a number of her close neighbours receive broadband services, including her nearsest neighour, who receives his from BT!
Is some of the digital divide simply down to BT's ignorance of it's own infrastructure?
3. ian Bremner
Where I live,in the heart of 'Silicon Glen' and with a supposed cable connection of up to 10mbps our local download speeds are a popular joke among the IT community many of whom depend upon fast and reliable connections to make a living. Moral of tale? Don't believe all you are sold or told by any sales-team