By Peter Cochrane, 20 May 2009 08:00
COMMENT
Compiled at my home near Woodbridge, UK, and dispatched to silicon.com via wi-fi later the next day.
My office looks like Armageddon. There are cables, CDs, instruction books, cardboard boxes and ADSL modems covering most of the floor and desks.
Rather than clean up, I recently let curiosity get the better of me and decided to conduct some speed tests to make sure I am getting the most out of my dual ISP service. (See more details in my previous blog.)
Before I started the test, my two broadband lines were maxing out at 6.5 and 3Mbps respectively. During a stable period of the day I conducted speed tests with five different makes and types of router. Each cited result was the average of 10 measurement sets to ensure a reasonable level of stability.
Best to worst, the results spanned 5 and 2.5Mbps, through to 6.7 and 3.9Mbps.
So it looks as though I can scrape out an extra 1.1Mbps purely by choosing the best router in my possession.
With bandwidth so scarce, how can I resist?
I can't reveal the manufacturers/brands represented but the results look like this:
Just a word of warning should you decide to give this a go - do make sure you select a quiet time of the day or night. During the busiest hours my download speed changes dramatically (from about 2 to 6Mbps) due to contention - as depicted below.
There is one further feature I feel I should report: the fact the upload rate was pretty much the same no matter which manufacturer's router, or time of day, I chose.
Upload contention seemed to be totally absent and my rates reasonably constant no matter what the time of day or night, as seen in the graph below.
If, like most of us, you are suffering from the increasingly serious UK bandwidth drought, this technique may give you a much-needed boost of bits.
Comments
There are 8 comments. Join the discussion
1. anonymous
If you use Towerstream you would get symmetrical bandwidth!
2. Mike
One of the most cost effective options is to fit an I-Plate fitted to your phone socket. This is designed to remove interference from internal wiring. Not all sockets can use it
3. Richard
Did all routers use the same settings?
Had eg. packet lengths been optimised?
Any other useful tweaks?
4. Peter Cochrane
Anonymous = Sorry to say that they are not available here - and on copper - symmetry comes at the price of a lower overall rate due to the crosstalk. Peter
5. Peter Cochrane
Mike = Yes indeed - that (iSocket/Plate) can give you a little more - as can tidying up your wiring inside a outside the home & office. Peter
6. Peter Cochrane
Richard = As far as I can tell I had them all operating in the same mode. I knew there was likely to be a significant variance before started because a lot of people had mentioned that Router A was better than Router Z etc. This prompted me to play with what I had available.
I have a few further ideas to check out, but I may be scraping the bottom of the barrel!
Peter
7. Rob
Peter = a most interesting article, thank you. If you email me the manufacturers/brands I would happily share this useful information as an independent voice!
8. Phil
Peter - if you wanted to find out what the better routers were ... where would you go to find out the comparison?
Can you forward your manufacturers list to me?